Skip to main content

On the Dvorak Simplified Keyboard

This is a post that I have been meaning to write from quite some time. Long hours spent typing code on my computer left my hands fatigued, and left me with a lot of pain in my wrists and fingers. That is when I decided to use the Dvorak.

But I have got the same bad habit as Dr. Watson, to tell a story backwards. Of course, you must be wondering what the Dvorak is.

The story of keyboards starts with the invention of the typewriter. Christopher Sholes, the inventor of the typewriter, tried with a two row piano style keyboard. But then, he got into many difficulties with the design. Then he finally settled for a four row design. This was similar to the QWERTY layout that most computers and typewriters today possess. The engineers at Remington, to whom Sholes had presented his design modified the layout a little further, and then the QWERTY was born.

As typewriters became popular, people got used to the layout, and started practising touch typing, i.e. typing without looking at the keys. And the layout became so popular, that the electronic typewriters that followed, and the computers after them too had the same layout.

But there was an essential defect in the design of this layout. It was done by an engineer for his own convenience, and not for the convenience of the people using it. Also, there was the issue of typebar clashes, and the layout had commonly used letters spaced away to decrease typing speed. However, other typewriters that did not have the typebar mechanism used some alternate layouts, most popular being the Blickensderfer typewriter in 1893. It featured a type wheel instead of the typebars, and hence could afford to increase efficiency of the typist. It had a layout which had the keys DHIATENSOR on the home row, these 10 letters being the most frequently used letters of the alphabet.

In 1936, Dr. August Dvorak came up with a newer layout. His logic was to give the most frequently used letters a place on the home row, so as to prevent unnecessary finger motion. He pet all the vowels on the left side of the home row, and the consonants DHTNS on the right side. All in all, the letters on the home row are AOEUIDHTNS, very similar to the Blickensderfer, with the exception of the letter U, which was added in the Dvorak, and R which was removed. The design of the Dvorak means that most of the time, hands alternate between letters, which is a good thing, as one hand can take its position over the a letter while the other hand types the previous letter. Also, the Dvorak tends to avoid awkward hand movements like hurdles, in which one hand must go from one row over the home row to the other extreme (try typing MINIMUM on the QWERTY), while typing consecutive letters. All this reduces typing errors, and helps reduce strain while typing, and also helps the typist speed up.

Then why is the Dvorak not popular today? A simple answer is that people are resistant to change. And most do not know the reasons for the QWERTY. This reminds me of a hilarious experiment with monkeys. The experiment involves putting five monkeys in a cage, and to put in a banana at the top of some stairs in the cage. As soon as any monkey touches the stairs, spray the remaining monkeys with cold water. Soon, the monkeys realize what is happening, and beat up any monkey that tries to reach the stairs. Once this basic training has been achieved, replace one monkey with a new one, who has no idea about what happens when he reaches the stairs. At this point, he shall naturally try and reach for the banana, and the other monkeys will try and hold him back. Then replace another of the old monkeys. Then, when the new entrant tries to reach for the stairs, the other monkeys shall beat him up. The monkey previously unaware of this custom too joins in the beating up of the new entrant. Go on replacing monkeys until none of the old monkeys remain. Now, none of the monkeys are aware of the threat of the cold water, but they still shall not allow any monkey to approach the stairs. And this is how company policies are made, and why people use QWERTY.

So, how to initiate the switch from QWERTY to Dvorak? It starts with a reorganization of the keyboard layout. For this, a recommended approach is to stick labels with the new characters over your existing keyboard. I have simply removed the key caps from my keyboard and replaced them in the new layout. The next step involves changing your software to accept the Dvorak layout. In Windows, you need to go to the control panel, then in the keyboard and input methods, select the layout as USA Dvorak International. Remove the existing US layout, and reboot your computer for the settings to be applied properly. A similar thing can be done in Linux too.

The Dvorak simplified layout
The Dvorak simplified layout

Then comes possibly the most exasperating task of all... reprogramming your fingers to the new layout. A useful tutor can be found here. Of course, you are free to choose any tutor that you like.

So how do I stand? Two month into the Dvorak, I am almost as good as I was with the QWERTY. Of course, I do make some mistakes, but they are becoming less frequent as I type more. From a mere 10 words a minute, I have come up to 60 words a minute in the span of the two months, and typing long blog posts like this has become so easy. I think that switching to the Dvorak is practical and easy, and should be attempted by all, because we no longer have to think and worry about typebar jams any longer.

Popular posts from this blog

Progressive Snapshot: Is it worth it?

I turned 25 last year, which in the highly mathematical and calculating eyes of the US insurance industry meant that I had suddenly matured into a much more responsible driver than I was at 24 years and 364 days of age. As a result, I expected my insurance rates to go down. Imagine my surprise when my insurance renewal notice from GEICO actually quoted a $50 increase in my insurance rates. To me, this was a clear signal that it was time to switch companies.Typically, I score really high on brand loyalty. I tend to stick with a brand for as long as possible, unless they really mess up. This qualified as a major mess up. As a result, I started shopping for insurance quotes.Two companies that quoted me significantly lower rates (30%–40% lower) were Progressive and Allstate. Both had an optional programme that could give me further discounts based on my consenting to the companies tracking my driving habits. Now, I am a careful driver – I hardly ever accelerate hard. I hate using the brak…

Cornell Graduate Students United: At What Cost?

On Monday and Tuesday, we graduate students at Cornell will be voting on whether or not we want to unionise. Actually, scratch that, only graduate students who hold a TA, RA, or GRA appointment can unionise.This is a shitty arrangement, and I will be voting against it.For those of you who are not aware of how graduate school works at Cornell, you could be on one of many appointments.FellowshipA graduate student on a fellowship gets a stipend and tuition paid without associated teaching or research opportunities. Graduate students on a fellowship typically work towards their own theses, but will be excluded from the unionGraduate research assistantshipsA GRA gives a graduate student stipend and tuition without teaching responsibilities. However, this money comes out of a specific project grant, and the students typically work on their own theses. Students on GRAs magically qualify to join the union, whereas there is virtually no difference between a GRA and a fellowship for the most pa…

Reading List, April 2017

Adam Carroll, When money isn’t real: The $10,000 experiment, in TEDxLondonBusinessSchool, 9 July 2015. [Online]: Carroll presents an interesting point – we have abstracted away money through the use of a number of instruments, such as credit and debit cards, NFC payment systems on our phones, and in-app purchases, when we don’t realise how much we are actually spending. Carroll spends some time showing how his kids, aged 7–11 played monopoly differently when they were playing with real money. He goes on to lay his premise, that financial literacy must be taught to children at a young age, when they should be allowed to fail and learn from their failures at a small scale, not at the hundreds of thousands of dollars when they are in student loan debt and just out of college.Carroll’s talk hit a lot of notes with my own experiences with money, and I’m sure that it would resonate with your experiences as well.Brett Scott, If plastic replaces cash, much tha…